IRS Tax Investigations: Five Things You Should Know

Each year hundreds of people in Arizona, particularly small business owners, learn that they are being investigated by the IRS, sometimes for criminal matters. Here are a few things you should know, right at the beginning.

Audit vs. Criminal Investigation

First, there is a huge difference between an IRS civil audit or collection action, and an IRS criminal investigation. The former are handled by revenue or collection agents, while the latter are handled by specially trained agents from the IRS Criminal Investigations Division. The goal of the former is to determine and collect unpaid taxes, while the goal of the IRS CI Special Agent is, bluntly, to put you in jail.

Tax Years & Form Types

Second, the IRS will almost always specify what tax years are being investigated and for which tax returns. For example, a small business owner might be subject to investigation for both his personal federal income taxes and also his business taxes. It’s important, at the very beginning, to know what tax years are at issue, and which taxes.

Nature of Taxpayer Malfeasance or Nonfeasance

Third, there’s a huge difference between an investigation for failure to file tax returns and tax fraud or evasion. The former is generally a misdemeanor, while the latter, tax fraud or evasion, are serious felonies.

Unreported Income vs. Improper Deductions

Fourth, in the case of filed returns, the criminal malfeasance often falls into two general categories: unreported gross income or improper deductions.

The former is usually income that should have been reported on the tax returns but was left out, often cash or “under the table” payments, commonly associated with service industries, including restaurants, entertainment, construction or landscaping. The latter might include large ticket consumer items that look immediately suspicious when deducted.

Most importantly, however, in criminal tax investigations, IRS CI Special Agents look for multi-year violations and patterns of “concealment.”

Managing an IRS Criminal Investigation

Fifth, it might sound surprising, but many IRS criminal tax cases can be settled before indictment. This means, before you are ever charged. Normally prosecutors initially charge people with a crime, then work out a plea with a defense attorney later. In stark contrast, criminal tax investigatory procedure allows adept attorneys to work early in the case with IRS, and DOJ prosecutors to sometimes avoid indictment altogether. This might sound too good to be true, but if handled early, aggressively, and well, is a possible outcome.

IRS CI Special Agents & Your Rights

Finally, in my experience, IRS CI Special Agents, almost all accountants, are not only highly trained and astute, but, as a rule, courteous, polite and professional. They will often come to your home or business and surprise you, politely asking you a few simple questions.

It is important to remember, however, that even though they are polite, that you may politely decline to speak with them without the presence of an attorney, and do so without offending them. Giving you the opportunity to retain counsel before giving a statement to federal law enforcement agents make good legal sense in nearly all cases, as they should recognize.

Conclusion

In sum, in these matters, it is important to early recognize the case as an IRS criminal investigation, understand the specific nature of the alleged misconduct, and consider declining to make uncounseled statements without first consulting or engaging experienced counsel.

Recommended Articles

Does Arizona Law Enforcement Use the New Clearview AI Facial Recognition App?

It is unknown whether any Arizona law enforcement agencies are using the new facial recognition technology sold by a company called Clearview AI.

Arizona Courts Signaling Greater Scrutiny of College Sexual Assault Discipline Cases?

The Arizona state courts may have signaled a new willingness to intervene in campus sexual misconduct cases in a case called Doe v. AZ Board of Regents.

If I am not a U.S. Citizen and I am Charged with a Crime, Do I Also Need an Immigration Attorney?

If you are not a U.S. citizen and you are charged with a crime, you might eventually need an immigration attorney.

Arizona sentencing reforms: Long overdue but finally on the way?

Arizona has one of the highest incarceration rates in the United States and remains out of step with sentencing reform trends across the country.

About Michael Harwin

Michael’s skill and experience have been recognized repeatedly. He holds an A-V 5/5 preeminent rating by Martindale Hubbell. He has been named one of the top lawyers in Arizona by Southwest Superlawyers, and one of the best lawyers in Tucson by Tucson Lifestyle Magazine. He also has been named one of the best lawyers in the United States by BestofUS.com , and given the highest rating possible by AVVO, 10/10 Superb.
Amazon Books