Former Informants Are Not Protected Group

In Hernandez-De La Cruz v Lynch, 819 F.3d 784 (5th Cir. April 26, 2016), the Fifth Circuit affirmed in part the denial of Hernandez-De La Cruz’s applications for withholding of removal under section 241(b)(3) of the Immigration and Nationality Act, which allows for withholding of removal if, “the applicant would face other serious harm in the place of suggested relocation; any ongoing civil strife within the country; administrative, economic, or judicial infrastructure; geographical  limitations; and social and cultural constraints, such as age, gender, health, and social and familial ties.” Id.

The application for withholding was based on De La Cruz’s claims that he was kidnapped and assaulted by members of the Zetas, a Mexican criminal syndicate, who released him only after he agreed to pay $15,000. When he reported the incident to the Mexican police in defiance of the Zetas’ instructions, corrupt officers beat him.

However, the IJ denied the application and the BIA affirmed.  De La Cruz argued at the 5th Circuit that the IJ and BIA erred in rejecting his claim that, he would be threatened with persecution in Mexico based on his “membership in a particular social group or political opinion.” See 8 U.S.C. § 1231(b)(3)(A).

The panel observed:

Although a local journalist reported that Petitioner had been beaten, it does not follow that his proposed group of former informants has “social distinction” or would be perceived as a particular group, because—according to factual findings that we lack jurisdiction to reconsider—the members of Petitioner’s proposed group are not substantially different from anyone else in the general population who resists the Zetas or otherwise threatens their interests.

The Fifth Circuit held:

To establish that he was persecuted based on his membership in a particular group, Petitioner must show he is a member “of a group of persons that share a common immutable characteristic that they either cannot change or should not be required to change because it is ‘fundamental to their individual identities or consciences.’ Orellana-Monson v. Holder, 685 F.3d 511, 518 (5th Cir. 2012) (quoting Mwembie v. Gonzales, 443 F.3d 405, 414–15 (5th Cir. 2006)).”

Thus, the Fifth Circuit noted: “There is no indication that an incorrect legal standard was applied or that it was legally erroneous to conclude that former informants do not constitute a particular social group.”

Recommended Articles

sealed letter
Sealing Criminal Records in Arizona Under The New Law

Arizona’s new sealing statute is a powerful way for people who have been charged or convicted of many common offenses, to be able to say “no” in many instances.

angry men arguing
Aggravated Assault in Arizona: Five Things You Should Know

In Arizona, “Aggravated Assault” charged under ARS § 13-1204 is a Class Four Felony, and in some cases with mandatory prison.

Police Misconduct & How it May Affect Your Criminal Case in Arizona 

DUI or domestic violence police misconduct even if not resulting in grievous misfortune can sometimes provide a helpful remedy for the criminally accused.

Collateral Consequences of Misdemeanors For Professionals & Parents in Arizona: Fingerprint Clearance Cards

people are surprised by how outsized the consequences some misdemeanor convictions can be. collateral consequences—meaning all those hidden consequences.

Federal Court Strikes Law Prohibiting Guns For Some Accused of Domestic Violence

For thirty years two federal laws prohibited all those convicted of misdemeanor domestic violence offenses from ever possessing firearms.

Michael Harwin

About Michael Harwin

Michael’s skill and experience have been recognized repeatedly. He holds an A-V 5/5 preeminent rating by Martindale Hubbell. He has been named one of the top lawyers in Arizona by Southwest Superlawyers, and one of the best lawyers in Tucson by Tucson Lifestyle Magazine. He also has been named one of the best lawyers in the United States by , and given the highest rating possible by AVVO, 10/10 Superb. Amazon Books